Skip to content
Discover how to find and nurture urban wildlife. Tips, guid…

Russia's School Messaging Spotlighted by an Academy Award-Winning Documentary – Is It Actually Effective?

When her seven-year-old daughter was instructed to learn a poem praising Russia's "mighty army" for a school function, a mother from Moscow felt it was excessive.

She has found it challenging to insulate her child from a growing number of so-called "patriotic" initiatives in the education system.

This intensification of military propaganda aimed at Russian youth has been powerfully depicted for a international audience in an Oscar-winning documentary.

The film, featuring footage from a ex- teacher and videographer from a provincial town in the Urals, documents how school activities were increasingly integrated with pro-government narratives following the full-scale military action of Ukraine.

What troubles the mother deeply is that her daughter actually enjoys participating in the government-sponsored programme.

"She adores her teacher, she likes her classmates – she enjoys feeling like a part of it," she says.

The mother fears that publicly opposing school activities could socially isolate her daughter. On one occasion, when she kept her child home to avoid a patriotic event, her daughter was upset. "I don't want her to feel like she doesn't belong," she adds.

The Film's Revelations

The documentary details how the filmmaker was reluctantly swept up in the government propaganda apparatus.

Additional rituals and compulsory lessons were rolled out, focused on the official perspective on Russian values.

Educational materials were revised to incorporate the latest developments, termed as a "special military operation."

These diktats have persisted. Just last month, the government announced plans for a state-approved list of toys and games for nurseries to promote "traditional Russian values."

The intended messages are unambiguous: the invasion is necessary, and loyalty requires full support. In private, however, some families hear different views.

Young Students' Experiences

One young boy, Maksim, excitedly lists what he has been taught in his "values" lessons: subjects ranging from arts and culture to friendship and even robots and tanks.

"They told us this is how to prepare for war," he states.

His mother, Marina, refrains from openly discussing her views in front of him, fearing he might repeat it outside.

"A vocal dissenting position might attract unnecessary attention," she explains.

Expert Analysis

Navigating the divide between official narratives and family beliefs is challenging, says a child psychologist.

"A child has to live in this environment – going to school, being part of the group," she says. "This doesn't mean parents should agree with the propaganda. But there is no need in taking a political stance in front of your child."

She suggests parents focus on universal values like the sanctity of human life and peaceful conflict resolution – instead of openly challenging the school narratives.

Studies indicate younger children are particularly receptive to messages from authority figures. "If you tell a small child that war is necessary, they will accept it," she adds.

"If parents consistently diverge with institutional messaging, family influence usually wins out in the long run," states a university expert in behavioural genetics.

However, when the state controls nearly all sources of information and alternative narratives are limited, the outcome is less predictable. This is the case in the current Russian environment.

Research into 20th-century state education suggest that systemic messaging can have enduring effects, especially when reinforced by the wider culture.

Varied Implementation

The enforcement of government guidelines differs significantly across schools.

Certain schools embrace them enthusiastically, while others soften or quietly resist the requirements. Educators may modify, downplay, or ignore the official content.

In footage from the documentary, children are shown given Russian flags during a school assembly to listen to a speech about a state-run children's movement.

In a separate lesson, a class is warned that the "opposition" will try to influence from within their communities.

Teenage Disengagement

The patriotic lessons, called "Important Conversations," are frequently met with indifference by older students.

One 14-year-old from St Petersburg, Maia, says they are "tedious."

"Hardly anyone engages in the discussion. We just sit and pretend to listen, then leave," she describes.

"Compelling citizens to engage in rituals of patriotism is a way of reminding them of the state's overwhelming power," explains a academic expert in Russian studies. This feeling is strengthened by controlled information and orchestrated public events, he adds.

In a move to capitalize on this "environment," authorities made easier the pathway for school-leavers to join the military in 2023, sometimes offering financial incentives as motivation.

Maia, who holds her parents' critical view of the war, avoids the topic at school and is unsure what her peers truly think.

"At first I was anxious that I would clash with those who backed the war," she remembers. "Now, people acts so cautiously that the atmosphere seems ordinary."

MH
Written by

Monica Hughes

City-dwelling naturalist and urban ecology enthusiast sharing practical ways to rewild your neighborhood.

Urban Wild Place

Type to search articles.